Skip to main content

10 Effective Tips for Insurance Email Marketing

November 29, 2023

Email is one of the oldest and most effective forms of digital communication. It is, without a doubt, a must-have in every digital marketer’s arsenal. This article will highlight the advantages of email marketing and offer practical advice for creating effective email campaigns.

What is email marketing?

Email marketing means sending commercial messages to build relationships with potential customers, strengthen your bond with existing clients, and even attract new business through targeted campaigns. However, it is important to note that e-mail marketing is subject to the CAN-SPAM Act, which requires each email to provide the option to opt out of being contacted. This means that while e-mail marketing is a valuable tool, it is also regulated and must be carried out in compliance with the law.

Benefits of email marketing

Did you know email marketing is one of the most profitable marketing channels?  For every $1 spent on email marketing, the average return on investment (ROI) is $36, making it one of the most profitable marketing channels1. With over 4 billion2 email users worldwide, email marketing allows you to connect with many potential customers and deliver targeted content to specific audience segments. Plus, you can track and analyze campaign performance to refine your strategy, improve messaging, and optimize your results.3 It’s a great way to connect with your audience and get the most out of your marketing efforts!

Consider email marketing automation

Email marketing automation is a game-changer for insurance agents. By setting up automated workflows and triggers, you can streamline your email marketing efforts, save time and resources, and ensure that your subscribers receive timely and relevant content to drive engagement and conversion.4

For instance, they can create personalized, automated emails that are sent to new subscribers, follow up with potential leads, remind customers of abandoned carts, or send personalized birthday greetings to existing clients.

Learn more about navigating technology, marketing automation, and Agency Management Systems.

Navigating technology: Agency management system capabilities for growth and retention.

10 effective email marketing tips for insurance agents

Email marketing is essential for improving brand awareness, encouraging your audience to take action, and, most importantly, engaging and retaining customers. Let’s explore some useful tips for successful email marketing:

1. Build your email list and keep it updated

Building an email list is the starting point for any successful email marketing strategy. There are many ways to grow an email list, such as incorporating a sign-up form on the website, promoting sign-ups during events, running marketing campaigns with social ads, and crafting gated content pages that require a sign-up for downloading an e-book or whitepaper. Keep your list healthy by removing inactive subscribers to improve delivery rates and campaign performance.5

2. Offer a personalized experience

To truly engage customers and increase the open rate of emails, offering a personalized experience is key. Gone are the days of generic, one-size-fits-all email content. Today’s consumers expect tailored messages that meet their needs and preferences. By segmenting your email list based on demographics, preferences, or past interactions, you can deliver content that resonates with each individual. By doing so, you capture their attention and build trust and credibility.

3. Define and understand your target audience

Thorough research and analysis of your current and potential customer base can provide insights into their demographics, preferences, and behaviors. Understanding their pain points and desires allows you to offer valuable solutions and build a strong connection with your recipients, becoming their trusted advisors.

Investing time in defining and understanding your target audience will result in higher open and click-through rates, ultimately improving conversions. Put in the effort to get to know your audience and see your email marketing efforts yield greater success.6

4. Use different types of email campaigns

Experiment with various types of email campaigns, such as newsletters, promotional emails, or educational content. This variety keeps your subscribers engaged and prevents your emails from becoming repetitive.

Different types of email campaigns.

5. Choose your email marketing platform

Choosing the right email marketing platform is essential to the success of an email marketing strategy. With so many options available, it is important to consider a few critical factors, such as your budget, the type of emails your business needs to send, and the different features and functionalities offered by various platforms. The platform’s reputation, customer support, and user-friendliness for ease of use are also crucial factors to consider.7

Keep in mind that the email marketing software needs to integrate seamlessly with your current agency management system for smooth data transfer and increased efficiency.

For more on vetting tech partners, read:

Navigating technology: Controlling the conversation with providers

6. Don’t forget to set goals and keep track of results for your email marketing campaigns

Set clear objectives for your email marketing campaign and regularly monitor and analyze key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and conversions. This allows you to measure your success, identify areas for improvement, and make data-driven decisions, leading to higher engagement and better outcomes.

For more on creating a measurement plan, read:

Navigating technology: How to measure agency technology

7. Optimize your emails for different devices

Did you know that 68% of all emails are opened on a mobile device?8 Consumers have multiple devices at their fingertips, and they expect a seamless experience across all of them. This means designing responsive email templates that adapt to various devices’ screen sizes and resolutions. Other factors to consider are thumb-friendly navigation, concise copy, clear and compelling subject lines, and prominent call-to-action buttons.

By optimizing emails for mobile and tablet devices, insurance agents can ensure their emails are accessible, visually appealing, and engaging to a broader audience.

8. Always include a call-to-action (CTA)

Every email should have a clear and compelling call to action (CTA). Whether to request a quote, schedule an appointment, or download a guide. Without a well-defined next step, your audience may be left unsure of what to do next, resulting in missed opportunities for engagement and conversions.

To make your CTA more effective, use persuasive language and highlight the benefits they will receive. Using urgency or exclusivity in your CTAs can create a sense of importance and motivate your customers to act promptly.

9. Choose the right subject line

The subject line of your email can really make a difference in how successful your campaign is. Think about it – the subject line is the first thing your recipients see when they receive an email. Make your subject line attention-grabbing, concise, personalized where possible, and relevant to increase open rates and engagement.

Another important thing to consider is A/B testing. It’s a great way to test a few different subject lines and see which one gets the highest open rates. So, give it a shot and choose the subject line that works best for you!9

10. Timing matters

The best time to send emails varies depending on your target audience and industry. So, take the time to analyze your audience’s behavior, experiment with different send times, and use data-driven insights to optimize the timing of your email campaigns.

Consider factors such as the time zone of your recipients, especially if your target audience is spread across different regions. By scheduling your emails to be delivered at the right time, you increase the chances of them being seen and opened promptly.

In summary, email marketing offers insurance agents a cost-effective, targeted, and measurable way to reach a large audience, ultimately driving business growth and maximizing ROI. By implementing these ten tips, agents can optimize their email marketing campaigns and achieve their marketing goals.