The Agency Forward editorial team is comprised of a group of thought leaders and contributors across Nationwide P&C as well as many others who provide support behind the scenes.
Share How to increase insurance customer loyalty during the holidays November 18, 2026 The holidays are a busy, high-expectation time for your clients. With 29% of consumers reporting they stopped buying from a brand due to poor customer experience either online or in-person,1 the holidays bring an important opportunity for your agency to show up in ways that go beyond a renewal notice. When you consider that acquiring a new customer can cost five to seven times more2 than retaining an existing one, thoughtful outreach, timely coverage conversations and personalized service can turn seasonal goodwill into lasting customer loyalty. Here are four practical ways to strengthen relationships with customers, deliver more value and keep your agency top of mind throughout the holiday season and into the new year. 1. Insurance customer appreciation during the holidays The holiday season is the perfect time to show your customers how much you appreciate them and the trust they have in your insurance agency. Consider a small, thoughtful gesture, like a personalized holiday card, small gift, calendar, or hosting a holiday-themed gathering. You could share a recap of the year, perhaps you used feedback from customer surveys to make changes, the end of the year is a great time to share the improvements and show you value feedback. These efforts can increase meaningful communication by creating a personal connection with your clients. Next steps: Building customer loyalty digitally 2. Activate an online review program for existing policyholders Online reviews are a powerful tool for building trust and attracting new customers. In fact, 71% of consumers regularly read online reviews when researching businesses, and 74% consult reviews on multiple platforms before making a purchase decision.3 Throughout the year when you’ve written a new policy or handled a claim with confidence, encourage your clients to leave reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, and social media. They not only provide helpful feedback for you and your team, but also potentially increase your agency’s online visibility and credibility. During the holidays, consider reminding customers to provide a review and you may be able to encourage them by offering small discounts or entry into a holiday raffle, but be sure to follow applicable laws. In the new year, consider adding the reviews to your website, or an email campaign. Next steps: How user-generated content and rave reviews benefit insurance agents 3. Conduct year-end policy reviews Year-end is an ideal time to review your clients’ policies to help them ensure they have the coverage that matches their life. It’s a natural time of reflection and planning, and clients can appreciate the value you offer during a time that often includes increased expenses. Reach out to your customers to schedule a review meeting, where you can discuss any changes in their circumstances and suggest possible adjustments to their policies. This demonstrates your commitment to personalized service and helps identify opportunities for additional coverage. Setting up automated reminders for policy reviews and sharing educational content on the importance of these reviews can make this process smoother and more effective. If your agency management system and CRM are connected, you can go a step further: a signal such as an upcoming renewal, a new driver or a recent home purchase can automatically prompt a review invitation, so the outreach reaches the client when it is most relevant. Next steps: Must-have year-end insurance policy review checklist to foster client satisfaction and loyalty 4. Utilize personalized insurance communication Tailoring your outreach to each client’s needs makes your communication more relevant, and using data-driven insights to send personalized messages, policy updates and reminders shows clients you understand their specific situation, not just their policy number. Personalized communication tends to build stronger relationships because it demonstrates genuine attention, and it increases engagement because the message actually applies to the person reading it. Segmented email lists for targeted messages and personalized holiday greetings are two practical ways to put this into practice. Next steps: Enhancing the insurance client experience with AI personalization Examples of personalized holiday messages If you’re looking for a starting point, here are a few ways agents commonly personalize their holiday outreach: Reference something specific about the client’s year, such as a new home, a new teen driver or a recent claim that was resolved smoothly. Thank clients by name for their continued trust, rather than sending a generic group message. Mention a shared detail, like a client’s hometown team making the playoffs or a local community event. Close with a simple, sincere wish rather than a sales pitch — the goal is connection, not conversion. Ready-to-use holiday email and text templates Consider these as a starting place to add your own communication style. Email template: General holiday appreciation Subject: Wishing you a warm holiday season Hi [Client Name], As the year winds down, I wanted to take a moment to thank you for trusting [Agency Name] with your insurance needs. It’s been a pleasure working with you, and I hope this season brings you time to relax and enjoy the people who matter most. If anything changes for your family or business heading into the new year, don’t hesitate to reach out. I’m always happy to help. Warmly, [Agent Name] Email template: Year-end check-in with a personal touch Subject: A quick holiday note (and a favor) Hi [Client Name], I hope your holiday season is off to a good start. Before the year closes out, I wanted to check in and see how everything’s going with [specific detail, e.g., the new house, the growing family, the business]. If you’d like, we can grab 15 minutes early next year to make sure your coverage still fits where life has taken you. In the meantime, happy holidays to you and yours. [Agent Name] Text template Hi [Client Name], just wanted to wish you a happy holiday season from all of us at [Agency Name]. Thanks for being a valued client this year. Reach out anytime if you need us. Frequently asked questions: Building insurance client loyalty When is the best time to send holiday outreach to insurance clients? Early- to mid-December tends to work well, giving clients enough time to notice and appreciate the gesture before the holidays get busy. Avoid sending messages too close to major holidays, when inboxes are already full. Should holiday messages include a sales pitch? Generally, no. Holiday outreach works best when it’s focused on appreciation and connection rather than selling. A soft mention that you’re available for a year-end review is fine, but the core message should feel like a genuine thank-you. How can small agencies personalize holiday communication without a lot of time or resources? Tailored email lists, comprehensive notes in your Agency Management System, AI prompts that include relevant examples and a list of go-to templates can help small agencies personalize outreach efficiently without starting from scratch for every client. If your agency management system and CRM are connected, you can connect with clients by life event or policy type and trigger the right message automatically. If you use AI to draft messages, decide upfront what it can do on its own and what needs your review before a client sees it. Citations/Disclaimers 1 “Retaining customers is the real challenge”, Bain & Company 2 “Consumer Trust in Online, Social and Mobile Advertising Grows”, Nielsen 3 “Share of One-Person Households More Than Tripled from 1940 to 2020”, United States Census Bureau Share
Managing your business and clients Navigating technology: Strengthen client relationships with digital education strategies November 22, 2024 Use tech-driven education to build trust, deepen understanding and enhance insurance coverage through ongoing engagement
Digital marketing Insurance marketing strategies for consumer and AI visibility August 24, 2026 As digital marketing trends adapt in the AI era, consumer behavior in the insurance space is also shifting.
Managing your business and clients Navigating technology: Connecting your tools to guide smarter agency decisions October 28, 2026 You already own more data than you use. Connect it to trigger the next best action across the client lifecycle.