Must-have year-end policy review checklist to foster client satisfaction and loyalty

Do you have a well-oiled process to conduct annual policy reviews with your clients?  

• Insurance gap analysis during an annual policy review is a systematic process that helps the client identify coverage shortfalls and optimizes policies to reduce risk exposure. Conducting reviews annually helps predict and prevent unexpected costs, ensures compliance, and strengthens risk management strategies.  

• Insurance agencies that conduct proactive renewal reviews retain 80% of customers who spoke to an agent that year, compared to only 65% retention among those who did not.¹ 

• 61% of policyholders have only one policy with their agent, while 29% have two and 10% have three or more—annual reviews are prime opportunities to increase these numbers.² 

Year-end reviews maintain agent-client engagement and offer a chance to provide personalized services, customized coverage, discuss the outside forces that impact insurance premiums³, and showcase insurance expertise. This approach enhances customer trust and brand loyalty by ensuring clients have sufficient coverage to safeguard their families, finances, and futures. 

Using a process and checklist approach to policy reviews builds credibility and positions you for long-term success with your clients and strengthens your role as a trusted advisor. 

Explore proven customer loyalty tips

Proactive insurance policy reviews for tailored coverage

Encouraging clients to proactively assess their insurance needs is essential for ensuring optimal coverage. Regular policy reviews help identify coverage gaps, enabling adjustments to reflect any life changes. This proactive strategy can prevent potential issues and ensure clients have the protection they need. Additionally, these reviews provide an opportunity to discuss risk prevention topics. 

Creating an effective insurance policy review checklist  

To improve the efficiency of the review process, your agency can develop a comprehensive insurance policy review checklist if you don’t already have one. This ever-ready resource can facilitate discussions and ensure all critical points are addressed with clients. Some key topics to include are: 

• Personal information updates: Verify contact details and update any changes in personal information. 

• Coverage adjustments: Assess current coverage levels and discuss needs. Adjust as necessary to reflect any life changes. 

• • Consider property value changes and revised replacement costs to inform any changes in coverage 

• • Inquire about change in marital status or if the family has grown 

• • For homeowners, discuss service line and equipment breakdown coverage for additional protection 

• • Ask clients if there are any home renovations or remodeling 

• • Inquire about protection for high-value purchases  

• • Discuss cybersecurity threats and the potential for email compromise, and coverage options 

• • Reassess the need for umbrella insurance to guard against the worst-case scenarios 

• • Discuss coverage reduction for student drivers living away from home without automobile access 

• • Ask about any home-based business, which is increasingly common in the gig economy⁴, and if they have rental properties 

• • Discuss life insurance policies, and potential revisions 

• Discount opportunities: Identify any new discounts the client may be eligible for, such as multi-policy discounts. 

• Policy details and coverage: Review the specifics of each policy, including deductibles, limits, and exclusions. Ensure there’s a clear understanding of the product and confirm that the policy still meets the clients’ needs or make the necessary adjustments. 

• Client feedback: Provide an opportunity for clients to share feedback on the service they received throughout the year.  

Share your feedback on the resources at Nationwide.com/marketing

Benefits of a Checklist during Annual Policy Reviews

Implementing a year-end policy review checklist confers several advantages to your business. This checklist standardizes procedures for your associates, streamlining their workflow. A written checklist minimizes the risk of omission and improves the likelihood that every client receives consistent and comprehensive service. Many clients appreciate your proactive communication and respect the expertise your agency offers, valuing your service over a mere policy renewal letter. 

How often should policies be reviewed?

Clients frequently inquire about the optimal frequency for policy reviews. Although an annual review is typically advisable, certain major life events are the catalyst for more frequent assessments. Such as significant renovations, purchase of high-value items, marriage, divorce, or the addition of a new driver. Additionally, the variability in commercial policies is influenced by business dynamics and cycles. Through your agency’s ongoing communications, keep your clients aware of trigger events for policy reevaluation, reaffirming that your agency is available to answer their insurance questions throughout the year.  

Maximizing year-end policy reviews to delivery specialized protection expertise

Year-end policy reviews are indispensable for insurance agents to provide guidance on insurance decisions, apply eligible discounts, deliver on the customer’s specialized protection needs and reinforce predict and prevent action items. Cementing in their minds that you are their trusted advisor. This best practice ensures clients have adequate coverage, fosters brand loyalty, and highlights your agency’s personalized service and expertise. When you commit to proactively inviting clients to annual policy reviews, you open the door to delivering specialized protection as a part of the unique value you offer your clients.  

Your takeaways 

Annual policy reviews are much more than a year-end task. Annual policy reviews are a strategic advantage. They help you retain clients, unlock cross-sell opportunities, and predict and prevent risks before they become costly. By using a checklist-driven process (either manually or automated utilizing technology or AI tools), you deliver consistency, showcase expertise, and strengthen your role as a trusted advisor. When clients see you proactively safeguarding their families, finances, and futures, loyalty follows—and so does long-term success for your agency.